11. 7.08
I Just Can't Seem To Get Passed This

I don't have a fun and light wedding post this week. In fact I haven't done any wedding planning, and I haven't even been excited about the wedding.

And I know why.

I'm sorry to belabor the point, but I am so upset about the passing about Proposition 8 in California and similar amendments in Florida and Arizona. I can't get excited right now about getting married, because in one night the rights of citizens in these states were stripped. Not to mention the citizens in states that had already passed similar amendments.

We can only wait and see if the 18,000 same-sex couples who married between June 16, 2008 in California will have their marriages invalidated.

In Florida Amendment 2 and in Arizona Proposition 102 also were approved and will amend the states' constitutions to exclude same-sex couples from marriage.

In Arkansas, voters approved a ballot measure that prohibits unmarried individuals or couples from fostering or adopting children effectively excluding gay and lesbian individuals and same-sex couples from the pool of adoptive and foster parents.

Why? Gay marriage is good for the economy. It doesn't minimize the commitment of or trivialize heterosexual couples in any way. It doesn't take rights away from heterosexual couples. And god knows there are children who desperately need homes and parents to love and take care of them.

Why can Josh and I decide to get married? We could get married tomorrow if we wanted to.

I guess I don't understand why people would go out of their ways to introduce this legislation that proactively targets a minority group. I don't understand how, in our country with the purported separation of church and state, we can change the constitution (at the state level, for now) to legalize discrimination. I don't understand how a state's constitution can be amended by a 52% vote. I don't understand why so many people, whose lives would be in no real way affected by such a decision would care so much that they would approve this legislation.

I don't know how we are supposed to go about our daily business and not be outraged by this, and I don't know what I can do about any of it.

Comments

Sarah said...

Dan Savage has commented on this thought-pattern in Savage Love, and his advice is something like "thank you for the support, but please keep getting married, and stay that way. It's when you Breeders divorce that hurts us!"

So, you know, fall in love, get married, and mean it.

And write angry letters to every representative you can think of.

mindy said...

Well stated.
Do you know what I'd like to see? I'd like to see how different this vote would have turned out if the following individuals weren't permitted to vote on it:
- people who have had a child out of wedlock
- people who have been married & then divorced
- married couples who have the ability/capacity/finances to adopt a child in need, but don't
Let's see how the vote turns out then!

mindy said...

I'm not sure if I'm making my point up there, but what I mean is that people are fucking hypocrites. So yeah, I agree with you.

Jilly said...

It's like you try to explain the logic behind these decisions...and you can't...there is no way to. I guess the only explanation is that people can be so f-ing lame and interpret something (like the bible) into a hate-mongoring doctrine.

Librarian Girl said...

I feel you, for sure. I just have to keep coming back to the idea that the days of discrimination against gay people are surely numbered. Those Propositions are not going to be around forever. The tide is turning- if you look at the big picture from Stonewall (and before) to now, we have come such a long way. It will happen, and I think it will be sooner than it feels like right now. We have to keep the faith.

Ivory said...

I like Jilly's response.
I don't get it either. Why do people care? It has NO effect on their lives and it just proves them to be mean and spiteful :(

Miss Dallas said...

I moved to Dallas not long after graduating college and becoming a newly minted taxpayer, a sunny-eyed youth looking to make it on my own. The first time I voted after graduating college there was a Texas state constitutional amendment on the ballot to ban gay marriage. I voted against it. It passed.

Needless to say, my eyes were less sunny after that.

Nothing like bad goverment to rob a young person's idealism.

Blinds said...

You can be excited about your wedding, although I understand how legislation like this might change your idea of what a wedding represents. It's horrible that people continue to be so closed minded. I agree with Librarian Girl, things will eventually change. There will come a day when we will look back in horror, like we do now w/ the fight for civil rights and women's suffrage, and not understand how we ever denied these basic rights to anyone. I hope it's sooner than later.

As far as what you can do about it, you are doing it, keep talking about it. Stay passionate about it and keep the conversation going months after Nov 4.

Ris said...

It is sad and hateful, and hopefully people will realize, and realize soon, that we cannot continue to think we have made great progress in equality while systematically shutting out a very real portion of the population. It is promising that so many of us out there are already outraged.

Byron said...

This post makes me realize why I love you.




< Go back and read Yoga Always Reminds Me Of Jill And Tanya And Planting Trees In City Park
Go forward and read My Bad >


Go back home